Navy, Gray, a little red, a little white
I like the those color combos but will also like the logo color to be interchangeable giving us maximum options.
Clean, sharp, modern look
NO CROSS IN THE DESIGN
Pursuit Church (name needs to be in the logo) ...I love the idea of the top of an arrow top pointing in the direction up. That could be a very simple look too, don't want a detailed arrow head/top. It could also be in the direction of north/west, don't want it going straight north, then it would look like a roof top-don't want that.
Love the idea of placing all of this in a circle...or be creative and place the entire piece in some cool shape.